FBAR CONSENT TO EXTEND STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS OPERATES AS A WAIVER/NON WILLFUL FBAR PENALTIES ASSESSED PER ACCOUNT

Law Office News

Published on

November 10, 2021
FBAR CONSENT TO EXTEND STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS

U.S. DISTRICT COURT DECIDES FBAR PENALTY STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS WAIVED AND

 ASSESMENT OF NON WILLFUL FBAR PENALTIES PER ACCOUNT

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida recently held that the statute of limitations for assessment of the FBAR penalty may be waived by the person against whom the penalty is assessed. In United States v. Solomon, No. 20-82236-CIV-CAN, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 210602 (S.D. Fla. Oct. 27, 2021), the Court concluded that the limitations period for assessment may be waived, even where the period for assessment has expired. In addition, the Court held that the assessment of the Non-Willful FBAR penalty is per account, rather than per form.

In the instant case, the Taxpayer failed to file FBARS for the tax years 2004-2010.  On March 13, 2012, the Taxpayer filed her delinquent FBARS as part of the Taxpayer’s participation in the Offshore Voluntary Disclosure Program (“OVDP”).

According to the facts outlined by the Court, Ms. Solomon then signed two Consent Agreements (the “Agreement”) entitled: “Consent to Extend the Time to Assess Civil Penalties Provided for by 31 U.S.C. § 5314.” The first Agreement, dated August 26, 2013 extended the statute of limitations to December 31, 2015.  Subsequently, the Taxpayer signed a second Agreement dated February 10, 2017, which extended the statute of limitations to December 31, 2018.

The Taxpayer and her tax advisor also signed Form 13349 (Agreement to Assessment and Collection of Penalties) on November 17, 2018, wherein the Taxpayer agreed to the assessment of Non-Willful FBAR penalties totaling $200,000. The total amount assessed represents the $10,000 Non-Willful FBAR penalty for each of the accounts for each of the tax years 2004-2010. Based upon the Taxpayer’s execution of the Agreements and Form 13349, the IRS assessed the agreed upon penalties on December 12, 2018.

The Taxpayer elected to forego paying the FBAR penalties, resulting in the United States filing suit in the early part of December 2020 in the District Court, seeking to reduce the assessment of the Non-Willful penalties to a judgment. In response to the Complaint, on February 1, 2021, the Taxpayer filed a Motion for Partial Summary Judgment (the “Motion”) in an attempt to limit the FBAR penalties to $70,000. The Taxpayer also argued in her Motion that the FBAR penalties should be assessed on a per form basis rather than based on a per account basis.

The Taxpayer’s  moving papers asserted that the Statute of Limitations for the tax years 2004-2009 should be time barred by reason of  31 U.S.C. § 5321 (b)(1).  In addition, the Taxpayer maintained that non-willful violations of 31 U.S.C. 5314 should be assessed on a per form basis rather than a per account basis.

The Taxpayer’s position is based upon the premise that the Agreements she signed did not have the effect of extending the statute of limitations, since the limitation periods had already expired.

In particular, the Taxpayer asserted that by the time she signed the first Agreement on April 26, 2013, the six year statute of limitations for the tax years 2004-2006 had already expired.  With respect to the tax years 2007-2009, the Taxpayer conceded that the first Agreement extended the statute of limitations until December 15, 2015, but maintained  that the April 26, 2013 Agreement had already expired by the time she signed the second Agreement on February 10, 2017.

In response to the Taxpayer’s Motion, the Government filed a Cross Motion for Partial Summary Judgement. In its Cross Motion, the Government argued that pursuant to 31 U.S.C. § 5321(b) (1), the six year statute of limitations is non-jurisdictional in nature, and as such, waivable. They also argued that the Taxpayer clearly and knowingly waived the limitations period by signing the two Agreements and Form 13349.

In addition, the Government argued in its Cross Motion that under the plain text and structure of Bank Secrecy Act and implementing regulations, the assessment of the Non Willful FBAR Penalties should be per account and not per form.

It is noteworthy that the procedural history of this case fails to mention whether the  Taxpayer opted out of or was removed from the OVDP, since the miscellaneous offshore penalty provided for in the  last iteration of the OVDP was a one-time  27.5% penalty based upon the highest aggregate balance in any one of the years in the disclosure period. The assessment of the Non-Willful FBAR penalties rather than the 27.5 miscellaneous offshore penalty under the OVDP suggests that the Taxpayer either opted out of or was removed by the IRS from participation in the OVDP.

The statute of limitations under 31 U.S.C. § 5321(b) (1) provides:

“The Secretary of the Treasury may assess a civil penalty under subsection (a) at any time before the end of the 6-year period beginning on the date of the transaction with respect to which the penalty is assessed.”

In its analysis, the Court stated:

“The key inquiry in determining if a limitations period can be waived is  whether the waiver limits courts’ subject matter jurisdiction—in which case its time bar is not waivable—or is instead a non-jurisdictional claim processing rule—in which case waiver is permissible.”  (See U.S. Dept. of Lab. v. Preston, 873 F.3d 877, 881 (11th Cir. 2017) (citing In re Pugh, 158 F.3d 530, 543 (11th Cir. 1998)).”

The Court concluded that 31 U.S.C. § 5321 (b) (1) did not operate as a limitation on the Court’s jurisdiction. The Court quoting from United States v Schwarzbaum 18-CV-81147, 2019 WL3997132, at *4 (S.D. Fla. Aug. 23, 2019) stated:

‘If a statute is not jurisdictional, then as merely an affirmative defense, the statute of limitations can be waived by the parties even for claims that have expired.’

In deciding in favor of the United States, the Court noted the absence of any reference to the Court’s jurisdiction in Section 5321 (b) (1), and concluded that the statute merely operates as an affirmative defense.

The Court also rejected the Taxpayer’s claim that she did not knowingly waive the limitations period when she signed the two Agreements, stating that:

“The language is clear, unambiguous, and unlimited…..”

Finally, the Court rejected the Taxpayer’s argument that the assessment of the Non-Willful FBAR Penalty should be assessed per form rather than per account.  In its decision, the  Court, citing United States v. Boyd, 991 F.3d 1077 (9th Cir. 2021), where the Court rejected the  Government’s position on the issue), observed that, with the exception of one case, Courts have consistently held that the assessment of the Non-Willful FBAR penalty is per account and not perform.

Signing an Agreement can have far reaching consequences for a Taxpayer and should first be carefully evaluated with an experienced tax attorney. In addition, the Taxpayer needs understand the context in which the waiver is being presented, as well as the expiration of the statute of limitations for each of the years in question.

This case is unclear as to whether Taxpayer opted out of or was removed from the OVDP, and if so, whether the assessment of the Non-Willful FBAR penalties exceeded the amount the Taxpayer would have otherwise paid under the OVDP.

Equally unclear is whether the Taxpayer’s tax advisor ever discussed the option of filing an appeal with the IRS. In some instances, Taxpayers have achieved favorable results in appeals.

Author

Anthony N. Verni

ATTORNEY AT LAW, J.D., CPA, MBA
With 20+ years of experience practicing before the IRS, I bring a rare combination of legal and financial expertise as both an Attorney and a Certified Public Accountant.
Contact Me

Why Trust Us

At Verni Tax Law, we adhere to a stringent editorial policy emphasizing factual accuracy, impartiality and relevance. Our content, curated by experienced industry professionals. A team of experienced editors reviews this content to ensure it meets the highest standards in reporting and publishing.

More Similar Posts

Loading posts...

Lorem Ipsum is simply dummy text of the printing and typesetting industry.

Table of contents

Hear from relieved
Taxpayers who trusted Verni Tax Law Around the World

Anthony was creative in helping me resolve some past issues in a way that they never became a problem so that is greatly appreciated and I feel confident I can now enjoy my retirement with peace of mind. Thanks for that.

Ken B.

Cebu City, Philippines

I came to Anthony Verni with FBAR issues. I was not sure what to expect and felt that I was going to be put in a difficult position financially as well as legally. My fears were unfounded and I was very satisfied with his professionalism and the outcome of my case.

Douglas R.

Osaka, Japan
Load more

Anthony’s help with Swift & Secure Systems Inc., CheckWare Workstations LLC and my personal taxes have been of great value. Since moving to Florida (and my Connecticut Accountant retiring) I have tried various other methods of keeping the accounting and taxes under control.

Phil Y

President, Swift & Secure Systems Inc., Boynton Beach, FL

I would like to thank Anthony N. Verni.   Mr. Verni has successfully represented us before the Internal Revenue Service. We had foreign bank accounts that we inadvertently didn’t report and we were subject to steep penalties. As a result his efforts, the FBAR penalties were waived by the IRS.
Thank You

Yassin and Eva, B.

Farmington Hills, Michigan

EXPAT solution for delayed US tax / FBAR issues
Anthony Verni helped us to file our delayed IRS tax returns and FBAR issues in a very professional way. We are very thankful for his help and guidance thru this nightmare of rules and are highly recommending his service.

Andrea

IRS FBAR and OVDI compliance representation expertise
As a long-term ex-pat US citizen living in Europe, I was surprised several years ago by an polite invitation from the IRS, via email, to consider filing FBARs, along with updated income tax returns. Although (or because) I am a university academic with specialization in comparative labor law, I quick…

Charles

Sound advice. High caliber work.

One of those people who were born by chance in the USA but never lived or worked there, in 2015 , I had no choice but to file returns with the IRS. For this purpose, fortunately, I found Mr Verni on the internet and entrusted him with the complex process involved in using the Streamlined Foreign Offs..Read more

Carlos

EXPAT solution for delayed US tax / FBAR issues

Anthony Verni helped us to file our delayed IRS tax returns and FBAR issues in a very professional way. We are very thankful for his help and guidance thru this nightmare of rules and are highly recommending his service.

Andrea

Verni’s professional services Review

Beside his inbepth knowledge of the law, Anthony will setup weekend appointments to accommodate his clients. I really appreciate that because otherwise I would have had to miss time, thus money from work.

Elder

Excellent service

Mr. Verni provided excellent service for my tax law matter and also income tax preparation. Highly recommended.

anonymous

Tax issues

Anthony Verni helped us resolve our tax issues. He guided us through the whole process and took care of the filings. He is extremely courteous and reassuring. He also explains the options available and advises what he thinks you should do.

anonymous

President
I have known and have had the pleasure of having Anthony Verni representing me on several projects over the last 20 years. I have always found him to be conscientious and diligent in working within my time restraints and goals. He has been dedicated and responsive in providing me with the the legal r..Read more

Frank Pirol

Offshore voluntary disclosure issues

Mr. Anthony Verni, your expertise and professionalism in handling my offshore voluntary disclosure case far exceeded my expectations. Thank you and appreciate for providing guidance, support and presenting the facts of my case. I simply could not have been more pleased with the process and outcome. ..Read more

Vikram Patel

The expat’s solution to US tax problems

I met Anthony after comparing advice and quotes from 5 different expat tax experts, all based in the U.S. I had an initial free telephone consult with Anthony about my issues with non-filing of Fbars for my foreign accounts investments. The other attorneys I contacted had advised me that the onl..Read more

Brian

Have questions or need guidance?

I’m always available by phone, email, or Skype whatever’s easiest for you.

Take the first step and let me help fix the root of your tax problems.